PL EN
When drinking-water quality indices disagree: a statistical comparison of five indices under Moroccan and World Health Organization reference values in the Saiss groundwater, Morocco
 
Więcej
Ukryj
1
Engineering Sciences and Applications Laboratory, National School of Applied Sciences of Al-Hoceima, Abdelmalek Essaâdi University, Tetouan, Morocco
 
2
Laboratory of Physical Chemistry of Materials, Natural Substances and Environment, Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Sciences and Techniques of Tangier, Abdelmalek Essaâdi University, Tetouan, Morocco
 
3
Geosciences Research and Development Laboratory, Department of Earth Sciences and Environment, Faculty of Sciences and Techniques of Al Hoceima, Abdelmalek Essaâdi University, Tetouan, Morocco
 
 
Autor do korespondencji
El Hammoudani Yahya   

Engineering Sciences and Applications Laboratory, National School of Applied Sciences of Al-Hoceima, Abdelmalek Essaâdi University, Tetouan, Morocco
 
 
 
SŁOWA KLUCZOWE
DZIEDZINY
STRESZCZENIE
Water quality indices (WQIs) condense multiple measurements into a single rating, yet their weighting, aggregation and classification rules may yield contrasting assessments of the same groundwater. We quantified agreement among five indices applied to 96 samples collected during four seasonal campaigns in 2025 from 24 wells in the shallow Saïss aquifer (Morocco). The weighted arithmetic WQI, inverse-standard-weighted WAWQI, CCME-WQI, Nemerow index (NI), and entropy-weighted WQI (EWQI) were each calculated using Moroccan NM 03.7.001 and selected WHO guideline or acceptability reference values for the same 13 physicochemical parameters. We evaluated class agreement using linearly weighted Cohen's kappa, ranking concordance using Kendall's W, and parameter influence using leave-one-parameter-out sensitivity analysis. Further checks examined the WAWQI weights with a dimensionally consistent parameter set, the influence of non-detected trace metals and the consistency of conductivity with the measured anions. Four wells exceeded at least one physicochemical reference value, whereas faecal coliforms were detected in all 96 samples (34–440 CFU/100 mL). Agreement among the ten index–reference combinations was limited at the ranking level (W = 0.53, p < 0.001). EWQI and CCME-WQI assigned identical annual classes (weighted κ = 1.00), but this did not establish equivalent sensitivity to individual exceedances. WAWQI showed negative agreement with the other indices (weighted κ from −0.25 to −0.16), reflecting the disproportionate influence of cadmium, which received approximately 72% of its total weight despite remaining below its reference value. This dominance is intrinsic to inverse-standard weighting rather than an effect of mixed measurement units: restricting the index to the ten parameters expressed as mass concentrations left the weight of cadmium at 72.5% and the classes unchanged. EWQI assigned nitrate only 2.2% of its weight. NI alone classified all four physicochemically non-compliant wells outside its best category. The results show that WQI classes are method-dependent screening summaries rather than determinations of drinking-water safety. Reporting should combine index scores with individual exceedances, weighting diagnostics, uncertainty considerations, and an independent microbiological assessment. The data matrix and calculation files are provided to allow independent reproduction of the results.
Journals System - logo
Scroll to top